The Ultimate Guide To Cooking Scallops The Right Way

The Ultimate Guide To Cooking Scallops The Right Way

Rediscovering Scallops

Scallops might just be the most underrated treasure of the seafood world. Despite their exquisite taste and texture, they rarely steal the spotlight in seafood discussions, overshadowed by the usual mentions of fish, shrimp, and lobster. This culinary gem seems to fly under the radar, unnoticed until it makes a star appearance on a dinner plate at a restaurant. Then, the compliments start pouring in: "That looks delicious," "It smells amazing," and the inevitable, "Can I try some?" followed by everyone sampling from the dish—a slight annoyance, admittedly.

It's high time for a cultural revelation to recognize the magnificence of scallops. Their appeal lies in their soft texture and subtle flavor, akin to shrimp and lobster but gentler, making them perfect for pairing with ingredients like garlic and lemon. The versatility of scallops is remarkable—they can be wrapped in bacon, pan-seared, or steamed and dipped in butter, always maintaining their delightful tenderness.

Despite their simplicity to prepare—making it hard to go wrong in the kitchen—scallops often remain an uncommon choice at seafood eateries.To spread the love for scallops, join the culinary adventure and discover why scallops should be your next favorite seafood choice.

Exploring the Diverse World of Scallops: Types and Culinary Uses

Scallops, a delectable type of saltwater clams, are a culinary treat that pairs wonderfully with garlic, butter, and lemon. Beyond their flavor, the term "scallops" encompasses various species of mollusks, but primarily refers to the meat harvested from these creatures. The U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) praises Atlantic sea scallops as an eco-friendly choice due to their sustainable and responsible sourcing.

Scallops come in several forms that might be confusing at first—wet, dry, diver, and dayboat scallops—but let’s focus on the basic categories: sea scallops and bay scallops, which differ significantly in size, taste, and price.

Sea Scallops

Large and robust, sea scallops typically measure 1 ½ to 2 inches in diameter and dwell in deeper ocean waters. They are also known by other names such as king scallops, great scallops, Alaskan scallops, or jumbo scallops. Their size makes them ideal for pan-searing, creating a crusty exterior with a tender, juicy center. Sea scallops can also be grilled, sautéed, or poached, but care must be taken not to overcook them. They are generally more expensive and considered a luxurious choice.

Bay Scallops

Harvested from the shallow waters of bays and estuaries along the East Coast, bay scallops are smaller and less costly than sea scallops, typically measuring between ½ and ¾ inch. Although not as highly regarded as sea scallops, they possess a delicious flavor and tender texture. Due to their small size, bay scallops are better suited for sautéing, deep frying, or adding to ceviche, rather than pan-searing.

Dayboat Scallops

Dayboat scallops are harvested using traditional chain drag nets that collect scallops from the seabed. They tend to be less expensive than diver scallops but have a higher environmental impact due to their mass-scale harvesting process.

Diver Scallops

As the name suggests, diver scallops are collected by divers who handpick them from the seafloor, choosing the largest and best-quality specimens. This method is more sustainable and environmentally friendly, minimizing damage to the ocean floor and surrounding ecosystem. Diver scallops are typically more expensive but are prized for their quality.

Wet vs. Dry Scallops

The market also differentiates scallops based on their treatment before sale. Wet scallops are soaked in a trisodium phosphate solution, which causes them to absorb water and increase in weight. This not only affects the price (as they weigh more due to the absorbed water) but also impacts their cooking properties, making them less suitable for recipes that require searing. They might also have a slightly soapy taste. In contrast, dry scallops are not treated with chemicals and are considered the better choice for culinary uses, especially for achieving a good sear.

Thawing and Preparing Scallops for Cooking

When it comes to preparing frozen scallops for cooking, it's crucial to handle them properly to preserve their succulent qualities. Here’s a guide to properly thaw and prepare scallops:

Thaw Gradually: Rushing the thawing process is a mistake, especially since scallops cook quickly due to their small size. Avoid using a microwave for thawing, as it can start cooking the scallops unevenly, leading to a chewy texture.

Refrigerator Thawing: The ideal method for thawing scallops is in the refrigerator. Allow them a few hours or preferably overnight to thaw slowly, which helps them maintain their texture and moisture evenly.

Quick Thaw Method: If you’re short on time, you can also thaw scallops quickly and safely by placing them in a strainer and running lukewarm water over them until they are fully thawed.

Dry Them Thoroughly: Before cooking, it’s essential to pat the scallops dry with a paper towel. Moisture on their surface can prevent them from achieving a golden, crispy sear, which is particularly desirable for dishes like pan-seared scallops.

Oil and Seasoning: Scallops are lean and mild in flavor, so to prevent them from drying out during cooking, use a generous amount of oil or butter. Seasoning them well enhances their natural flavors. This is crucial for both fresh and previously frozen scallops.

Even Cooking: If you find some scallops significantly larger than others, consider slicing them in half horizontally to promote even cooking. This prevents the larger scallops from being overcooked on the outside while still raw in the center.

By following these steps, you'll ensure that your scallops turn out perfectly cooked, maximizing their flavor and texture.

Mastering the Art of Cooking Scallops

Scallops are a delightful seafood treat, but they require careful cooking to prevent them from drying out or becoming chewy. Here's how to cook scallops perfectly, whether you're pan-searing, grilling, or broiling them.

Pan-Searing Scallops

  1. Preheat the Skillet: Use a high-quality skillet and heat it over medium heat.
  2. Add Oil: Pour 2 tablespoons of vegetable oil into the skillet.
  3. Season Scallops: While the oil heats, toss your scallops in a seasoning mix. For a breaded version, coat them in a mixture of flour and your chosen seasonings.
  4. Arrange Scallops in Pan: Place scallops in the pan, ensuring there is about a ¼ inch of space between each. Crowding the pan can hinder the cooking process.
  5. Cook Evenly: Sear each side for about 3 minutes, or until the edges are brown and the centers are opaque, totaling about 6 minutes.

Grilling or Broiling Scallops

  1. Marinate (Optional): For extra flavor, marinate the scallops for 10-15 minutes in an oil-based marinade before cooking. This is also a great time to prepare any accompanying vegetables.
  2. Prepare for Cooking: Remove the scallops from the marinade (keep the marinade for later use). Thread the scallops and any vegetables onto wooden skewers.
  3. Heat the Grill or Broiler: Preheat your oven's broiler or warm up your grill to medium-high. If broiling, grease the pan; if grilling, grease the rack.
  4. Cook on Skewers: Place the skewers on the grill or in the broiling pan, spaced well apart. Grill or broil the scallops for about 4 minutes on each side, brushing them occasionally with the remaining marinade.
  5. Monitor for Doneness: The scallops are done when they turn a golden brown. Be vigilant to avoid overcooking.

By following these steps, you'll ensure your scallops are cooked to perfection—juicy on the inside with a delightful crust on the outside, whether they are pan-seared, grilled, or broiled. This method brings out the best in the scallops' flavor and texture, making them a standout dish on any table.

Recommended Cooking Guild Products

Enhance your scallop cooking experience with these carefully selected tools from Cooking Guild:

Dynasty Series 8" Chef Knife

The Dynasty Chef Knife is exceptionally well-suited for preparing scallops due to its finely honed edge and perfect balance. The sharpness of the blade allows for precise, clean cuts without tearing the delicate meat, ensuring your scallops have a presentable, gourmet-quality appearance. The balance of the knife aids in controlled, effortless slicing and dicing of additional ingredients like garlic and herbs, which are often used to enhance scallop dishes.


  • Exceptionally Sharp: Ideal for making precise cuts, crucial for delicate seafood like scallops.
  • Perfectly Balanced: Enhances control and reduces fatigue during repetitive tasks.
  • High-Quality Materials: San Mai AUS-10 steel offers rust resistance and durability.
  • Ergonomic Handle: Carbonized rosewood ensures comfort and a secure grip.
  • Lifetime Warranty: Ensures long-term reliability and satisfaction.


  • Price Point: May be considered an investment piece due to its premium craftsmanship.
  • Specialized Care: Requires proper maintenance and hand-washing to preserve blade integrity.

Nomad Series 8" Chef Knife

The Nomad Series 8" Chef Knife is ideal for preparing scallops due to its precision and balance. The razor-sharp AUS-10 steel blade effortlessly slices through scallops, allowing for clean cuts without tearing the delicate meat. This is crucial when presenting scallops either as a main dish or in fine dining settings where presentation is key. The full-tang rosewood handle offers a secure grip, making delicate tasks like trimming and slicing scallops safer and more efficient.


  • Exceptional Sharpness: The AUS-10 steel ensures a very sharp edge that is perfect for making precise cuts.
  • Durability: Full-tang construction and high-quality materials ensure that the knife can withstand the rigors of daily use.
  • Rust Resistance: The stainless steel blade prevents rust, keeping the knife in excellent condition over time.
  • Balance: The knife is perfectly balanced, which reduces fatigue and allows for better control when handling delicate ingredients like scallops.


  • Price: As a high-quality knife with specialized materials, it may be more expensive than other chef knives.

Shop Cooking Guild Chef Knives

Dynasty Series Paring Knife

The Dynasty Series Paring Knife excels in the delicate tasks required in scallop preparation. Its razor-sharp edge effortlessly slices through scallops, allowing for precise cuts without tearing the tender meat. The knife’s size and balance make it ideal for the fine control needed to trim and prepare scallops perfectly, whether you're removing the muscle or creating intricate cuts for presentation.


  • Exceptional Sharpness: The high carbon content ensures a supremely sharp edge that cuts through scallops cleanly.
  • Durability: Built using the san mai technique, it offers enhanced durability and resistance to wear and corrosion.
  • Ease of Maintenance: The combination of high carbon and stainless steel allows for easy sharpening while maintaining rust resistance.
  • Ergonomic Design: The rosewood handle provides a comfortable grip, reducing hand fatigue during extended use.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: Elegant design with a rosewood handle and distinctive branding adds a touch of class to your kitchen toolkit.


  • None

Nomad Series Petty Knife

When it comes to preparing scallops, the Nomad Series Petty Knife is particularly effective. Its sharp, curved blade is perfect for the delicate task of cleaning and preparing scallops, ensuring minimal damage to the flesh and enabling fine, controlled cuts.


  • Precision Cutting: The sharpness and curve of the blade allow for precise cuts, which is crucial when working with delicate seafood like scallops.
  • Durability: Made with high-quality stainless steel, the knife is built to last and resist corrosion and rust.
  • Comfortable Grip: The ergonomically designed handle ensures comfort and control, reducing hand fatigue during repetitive tasks.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: The unique handle design and blade engraving make this knife a striking addition to any kitchen.


  • None

Shop Cooking Guild Paring Knives

The Heavy Duty Waxed Canvas Apron

The Heavy Duty Waxed Canvas Apron is crafted from premium, rugged materials, making it a durable choice for the culinary enthusiast. It features a water-repellent waxed canvas that ensures longevity and style in the kitchen. Designed for practicality, it includes two chest pockets for storing small essentials like markers, pens, or a phone, as well as two large front pockets and a kangaroo pocket for additional tools. Towel and tong loops offer quick access to necessary utensils, enhancing efficiency


  • Durability: The waxed canvas material can withstand the splatters and spills associated with pan-searing or frying scallops, ensuring the apron lasts through many cooking sessions.
  • Functionality: Multiple pockets allow for easy access to cooking tools and ingredients, which is particularly handy when timing is crucial, as it is when perfectly cooking scallops.
  • Comfort: The cross-back harness design reduces neck strain, which is beneficial when focusing on the precise cooking of scallops that require attention to detail.
  • Water Repellent: Ideal for the sometimes-messy process of preparing seafood like scallops, as it keeps you dry and clean.


  • Weight: While the apron is built to be durable, the heavy-duty canvas may be bulkier and heavier than lighter materials

Shop Cooking Guild Aprons

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best ways to cook scallops?

Scallops can be prepared through various cooking techniques. While pan-searing is preferred for its ability to create a golden crust while keeping the inside tender, other effective methods include broiling, grilling, or deep-frying, depending on your flavor and texture preferences.

2. How long does it usually take to cook scallops?

The cooking time for scallops generally ranges from 5 to 7 minutes, depending on their size and the cooking method used. Including preparation, the total time is usually about 10 minutes.

3. What is the recommended cooking time for pan-frying scallops?

When pan-frying, it's best to cook scallops for no more than 3 minutes per side. This timing ensures they are lightly browned and cooked to an opaque state, avoiding overcooking while maximizing flavor and texture.

Back to blog